My wife and I have many things in common but we have long disagreed over the “fun” of attending antique shows and tag sales. I figure I have enough used stuff laying around the house, why spend a hot day in the sun looking at more? In contrast, my wife delights in the hunt to find a treasure hidden in others’ trash — which she does regularly.
We found a compromise when I started carrying my camera with us on our tag sale expeditions. I’ve now shot thousands of frames of fascinating collections of garbage, heaped in all sorts of ways.
The image below is from one of these expeditions. It is a pile of used wooden stools. The flow of the tumble-down pile reminds me of a wooden waterfall.
One joy of using Photoshop is its ability to allow the user to take “snapshots” of variations on a theme. Here are a number of variations that resulted from my work on this image. While they show the path I took to my final image, you may decide that you would have stopped before I did.

The effect I was working toward was a more oriental, figure on ground effect. From here, I needed to darken the shadows while lightening or maintaining the colored highlight areas. For the PS geeks, in this step I just applied a curve, boosting the highlights and dropping the shadows.

The brightest of the highlights are beginning to wash out. Some may like the effect but it was not what I was aiming for, so I moved on.
I continued to darken the shadows while bringing down the top of the highlights.
For the PS geeks, I used a different set of curves and, on the fly, used my existing mask of the shadow area to cut out a copy of the shadows, placing the shadows on top of the image and using a blending mode of multiply. There are more graceful ways of doing the same thing but I anticipated using a layer effect to smooth the transition between the colored areas and the flat shadow. To do so, I needed a layer with its edges at the edge of the shadow.

I’m getting close here. I’ve got the flat black ground but I don’t like the rough edge where it meets the chipped paint on the stools.
From here, I smoothed out the edges of the shadow area and created some visual interest and the boundary between the highlight and shadow.
For the PS geeks, I tried working with a layer effect but did not find anything that pleased me. I then stamped the image, used a cutout filter, and blended only the dark part of the layer at about half opacity. I creates flatter appearance that I was seeking, as well as having the happy side effect of creating geometric shadows on the stools, further flattening the image.

At this point, I was pretty sure I was where I wanted to stop. I was a little bothered by the balance of figure and ground, particularly on the right side. As a result, I decided to compress the image and see if I like a different balance between the figure and the ground.
To do this, I used a really fun tool in Photoshop call “content aware scale,” It allows me to accordion an image with minimal change to its components. If you compare the red stool below with the red stool above, you will see that it has changed shape. It was the stool most effected by the change.

While this result appears more stable, when I look at it next to the earlier iteration, I find that I like the taller version better. It creates a more tumble-down feeling, which is part of what I was aiming to do.
You may have stopped sooner or may like the compressed version better. Again, a joy of Photoshop is I have both versions, can paste them on a wall and look at them for a while. It’s sort of like doing two paintings at once.
Finally, I love zoming in and looking around at the pixel-eye level. Here is an interesting view from the center of the pile.

Posted in 30 in 30, 2011, Advanced Photoshop, Figure-Ground, Pixel Eye View
Tags: Adobe Photoshop, Brimfield, cutout, Figure-Ground, flow, Photo manipulation, tag sale